Montana 1948

Sunday, October 18, 2009

House of Sand and Fog pp.280-324


House of Sand and Fog Study Guide- pp.280-324

1. “ I have seen one hundred men like this; they are desperate for something so they use their pistol the last minute but they are always bluffing.” (p281) In what way is the colonel’s assessment of Lester an ironic foreshadowing of Esmail’s fate?

2. The colonel was armed when he escaped Iran with his family. Why is he recalling this memory now? How does this relate to his confrontation with Lester? (p. 282)
3. “Thugs: these are people who hurt others merely to get things they want. Criminals, Esmail. Bad people.” (pp.284-285) How does Esmail react to this explanation? What does this say about the depth of his character?

4. “What is it I have done except provide for my family?” (p.285) What does Nadirah say to this that sheds light on Behrani’s true motives?

5. Why does the colonel tell Esmail to appear frightened and do whatever Lester tells them to do? (287)

6. “…the time has come for Colonel Massoud Amir Behrani to stand at the wall, to stand at full attention and face his accusers.” (p288) When did Behrani not take full responsibility for his actions? How has it come back to haunt him?

7. What is Kathy’s explanation for her suicide attempt? What is Lester’s reaction?
p.295)

8. The colonel says that when he worked along the roadside his God was testing him. How has this belief led him to the house on Bisgrove? Do you agree or disagree with this philosophy? (p. 301)

9. What important part does Lester’s empty gun play in the resolution of this story. Be very specific. (p.303)

10. “Your sh*t is my sh*t.” What exactly is Lester saying here to Kathy that is important for her to hear? (p.305)

11. Lester has planned for Kathy to get her house back. At what point do things unravel and begin the final downward spiral of the novel?

12. Until this point in the novel, the colonel has shown few redeeming qualities. How has Dubus made us pity him?

13. How has Behrani been made to pay for his actions? Does he deserve his fate? Why or why not?

Saturday, October 17, 2009

House of Sand and Fog pp.240-280

House of Sand and Fog Discussion guide- pp.240-280

Name_________________
Partner________________


1.Why is Lester flashing back to the day when his father left the family? (p.241) How does this affect his decision to divorce Carol?

2. Why do you think Nadi is so much more sympathetic to Kathy than her husband? (p.245)

3. At this point in the novel (p.245) “fog was so thick [Lester’s] headlights were reflected off it and he had to drive slow, and careful.” What does the fog symbolize in this passage?

4. Why is it ironic that Kathy uses Nadi’s sleeping pills to try to end her life? (p.248)

5. Behrani finally reveals his situation to Esmail. What has motivated the colonel to do this? How does Esmail react? (p251)

6. How does Behrani react when he sees Kathy in the bathtub? How does Nadi react?
Why does he say nothing when he knows that Esmail is watching? (p.252)

7. “I feel sorry for her. We should have moved, Bawbaw-jahn.” What does this statement say about Esmail’s character? (p254) Why does Bahrani not listen to his son’s advice?

8. What does Lester discover in Kathy’s car that sends him into the house? (p257)
How does the rest of the story hinge on this important development?

9. “ In this moment he is weak. And it is the weak who are truly dangerous.(p263)
Who is speaking here? To whom is he/she referring? Explain the quote in terms of
the plot line.
10 Interpret Lester’s mental state: “His face was a windowpane and the inside was
covered with flies. (p. 263)

11. Why do you think Lester begins sweeping the floor after breaking into the colonel’s house? (p. 264)

12. Leste wonders what had happened since the morning that could have put Kathy over the line. What assumption does he make that is probably true? (p268)

13. Describe what Lester discovers about the Behrani’s lifestyle that enrages him.(p.277)
Why does he narrator catalog these items in detail?

Themes in the House of Sand and Fog

The following is excerpted and modified from Book Rags- Guide to the House of Sand and Fog and is being used as a secondary source for educational purposes.

The House of Sand and Fog draws from classical and Shakespearean tragedy.

Hamlet- “Something is rotten in the state of Denmark.
The story begins with Hamlet’s uncle poisoning the King in order to
marry his wife and take over the throne. His father’s ghost appears to him and tells him he must avenge his death and set things to rights.
Kathy loses her father’s home due to a bureaucratic error that should have never occurred and should have easily been rectified. Things are not as they should be in the modern state of California. Note that Corona means crown in Spanish.
Behrani, a once powerful officer in the Shah’s employment is forced to flee for his life when the revolution totally changes the country into a theocracy. Far from being just, the ruling sect does away with all aspects of religious toleration and executes those who dare to protest.

Appearances and Realities
1.The novel begins with Behrani living a double life: he leaves home well dressed-then changes clothes and goes to work picking up trash for the Highway Department by day, acting as a convenience store clerk by night...then he changes back and returns home well dressed. He is challenged by the desk clerk at the hotel where he parks his expensive Buick because he enters the hotel in work clothes. No one challenges his right to be there once he has changed his clothing. Behrani clearly puts great stock in outward appearances.
2.His wife Nadi thinks that maintaining the appearance of wealth is essential to their daughter's finding a wealthy husband (indeed, such a marriage occurred shortly before the novel begins). Their expensive apartment is decorated in much the same manner as their home in Iran.
3.Kathy also tries to keep up appearances by not telling her mother that Nick has left her, pretending that everything is fine, which in a way she thinks it is, when she and Lester fall in love-but things are certainly not all right in the way she leads her mother to believe. Kathy goes out of her way to keep her mother from finding out the truth ..with a fictional earthquake that leaves the phone lines out

4. Appearances are also changed by the fog, which obscures even the most familiar objects close at hand, and comes and goes independent of human activity.
5. Appearances are also masked or changed when Nadereh, Behrani notices, starts using cosmetics again after moving out of the $3,000-per-month Berkeley apartment into the more ordinary Corona house.

6 And Kathy, when her eyes look strained from lack of sleep, applies a little eyeliner to disguise her tiredness.
7 Kathy’s mood is modified by her drug of choice- when she feels the least bit upset she smokes heavily. Breaking her sobriety when she meet Lester, she relies on alcohol to deal with stress. In the past Kathy relied on coke.- ironically, it its Lester who plants coke to trap a man who he suspects of abusing his wife. Behrani uses vodka to escape reality..something that would be forbidden to a Muslim.


At one point, Kathy appears to be dead after Behrani chokes her and drags what he thinks is her lifeless body into her car.
.The cruelest illusion, though, occurs near the end of the novel, after Lester, Esmail, and Behrani have left the white car and are walking toward the tax office: Esmail grabs Lester's gun and Behrani yells for someone to call the police; the police are summoned and they subsequently shoot and kill "the gunman," Esmail. Only Lester had known that the gun was not loaded. Thus, Esmail dies for nothing.
The American Dream and the Westward Migration
1 Kathy Nicolo's father, a man born of an Italian immigrant family, ran a linen business on the east coast of the U.S. He left Kathy and Frank a house in on its west coast.
2Kathy and her new husband Nick travel west in their Bonneville (as an interesting sidenote, a Captain James Bonneville was used by one of the first explorers of the U.S. Rocky Mountain West).
3 Kathy and Nick migrate to their new west coast home, making the crossing in a one-week nonstop trip. Kathy's memory of the trip is somewhat blurred-for example, when she imagines that the car was on cruise-control the entire trip (cars, of course, kick out of cruise-or burn up their motors-going up steep hills, like the Rocky Mountains).
4 Massoud Behrani had also migrated west. The first part of his journey was in a bulletproof limousine through the back alleys of the burning streets to his military base, where, as planned, his copilot had the engines of the plane they were going to steal already turned on.
Behrani flies west first to Bahrain, then Paris, and, finally, California.

House of Sand and Fog pp.172-217

pp172-217

1. In what way is Behrani’s family still vulnerable to Lester’s threats? (172)
2. Kathy makes a remark about Lester’s appearance. How is this related to what Behrani’s philosophy of personal respect? (175)
3. Kathy believes Nick’s addictions were related to his failure as a musician. How do you interpret this? Apply this to real world musicians. (176)
4. “The question was so ugly inside me…I was afraid it would come to life between us with fangs and claws.” (179) What is Kathy referring to here? How has the author to used this image rather than stating the fact? (181)
5. Despite all her flaws, Kathy says that sleeping with Lester and losing her dad’s house had been “…the final shove in a long drift to the edge.” (181) If you were Kathy’s therapist, how would you react to this news?
6. What mistake has Lester made to arouse Behrani’s lawyer’s suspicions of Lester’s visit? How does the lawyer follow up on this mistake? (183)
7. How does the colonel react to the officer who is investigating Lester? Is this something you would have expected? Explain. (185-186)
8. Behrani reveals he had a weapon in Iran that had a cowboy on a rearing horse etched on the grips. Relate this to his vision of the American dream. (186)
9. Nadi asks Kathy if her friend left any of his tools. What does this reveal about her understanding of Kathy’s conflict with the colonel? (189)
10. “You could be the twin of Soraya.” How does Kathy react internally to Nadi’s remark? (192)
11. What is the motivation behind the purchase of a tire iron at the hardware store? (193)
12. In his encounter with Kathy outside the house, how is Behrani repeating a pattern of physical and emotional abuse of women? Explain. (194)

13. What prevents Kathy from taking immediate legal action against Behrani’s attack? At what point and from whom could she have gotten help? (199)

14. How does Kathy’s brother Frank react to her news about Nick? What prevents her from telling him about the house? What does she expect from him that she is not getting? (197-198)

15. Describe Kathy’s desperate plan for dealing with the house. What events have driven her to this? (204-6)

16. Kathy’s discovery of Lester’s gun is probably a major turning point in this novel. Explain this in terms of what you know of the story so far.(207)

17. “For two days [Soraya] cried, though at the end she told to us she was very happy a broken angel had come to bless our house.” To what incident in the past is Behrani referring? How does he relate this to his encounter with Kathy ? (217)

18. At the end of Part I, Kathy is described as “. A sad drunken bird I found outside the door, a beggar angel asleep in our son’s room. How does this statement reveal a change in Behrani’s attitude towards Kathy? Do you think he is sincere?

House of Sand and Fog pp.145-172

pp145-172

1. How does Kathy manage to persuade her mother not to visit her? What does this say about her ability to relate to her mother? (p.147)
2. As Kathy drove away from her home, she pressed her hand on the car horn “all the way down the hill.” Explain the symbolism in this passage. (p149)
3. How was it possible that no one rescued Jasmeen from her fate at the hands of her father? Why do you think Bahrani tells this story in such detail? (pp. 150-152)
4. How did Behrani make atonement in the past for striking his wife?(p.153) How well does this work for him later? What pattern do you see here?
5. What incident makes it hard for Lester to leave his family? How does Kathy react to this? (pp.155-156)
6. What symbolism is inherent in Kathy’s river bath? (What is water usually associated with?) p.157
7. How does Lester rationalize his visit to Behrani’s house to Kathy? (p. 161)
8. What is behind Lester’s actions when he confronts the colonel? How does Behrani react to the visit? (pp. 165-167)
9. What does Esmail say in his conversation with his father that reflects his growing maturity? pp. 171-172
10. How much of what Behrani explains to his son about Kathy’s house is true? What have been his real motives?(pp.171-172)

House of Sand and Fog pp.95-143

pp.95-143

Interpret the following excerpts from the novel, using the questions to guide your response.


1.“Through the screen door at my back I smell…..”pg 95 par 3
How does this sensory image illuminate Nadi’s good mood, in contrast to the real situation that Behrani finds himself in?


2. Dear Sir,
I am writing to inform you that this firm…… (page 96 top)

Sincerely Yours,
C.S. Walsh, Attorney at Law

The author has chosen to reproduce Cathy Walsh’s letter to Behrani. What is the tone of this letter? In contrast, how does Behrani react? Is this normal ? Where might this confrontation lead later in the novel?

3. “When I hung up it was almost like I wasn’t anchored all the way to the ground.” (page 100 par 1) Kathy reveals her state of mind in this excerpt. If you were her therapist, how would you characterize her mental health? Predict an outcome for Kathy based on your diagnosis.

4. …men and women who have dressed in only T-shirts and blue jeans look up at me as I pass them by. They view my face, my suit, the valise under my arm, and as I return their eyes back to them, they look away as if I have come to collect something they cannot pay” (pp.104 bottom-105 top) What is the significance of how the people are dressed in contrast to Behrani’s? What do you think Behrani wants them to pay?

5. …my lovely daughter…dressed in an ivory satin, her long black hair tuck up upon her head beneath a spray of baby’s breath flowers which she wore like a crown. (p. 108 bottom- 109- top) Characterize Behrani’s relationship with Soraya based on this description. How might the story be different if Soraya were a major character with a

less selfish attitude?

6. “Shit, Lester, you do just what you want to do, don’t you?”(p.112 par 5)
In classical tragedy, this is called a fatal flaw. In what ways might Kathy’s
appraisal of her lover be valid? In what ways is it ironic?

7. “Sometimes I think husbands and wives, maybe they’re just meant t
get each other down the road, you know? Almost like it really doesn’t matter whether or not they stick around for the final act. Is that a sad way to look at it? (p. 116 bottom)
What is ironic about Lester’s philosophy of marriage? How does he use it to justify his affair with Kathy?

8. “The woman begins to pull away , but I squeeze her arm more tightly…” p127 top
This is indicative of how Behrani treats women. Where has he gotten this attitude? Where else has it manifested itself in the novel so far? What legal recourse should Kathy have followed that might have affected the plot of the story?

9. “She said it was her house …And it was taken away from her for no reason” (p142 bottom) This is Esmail’s view on Kathy’s dilemma. Why has the author chosen to include his opinion at this point? Define the word “innocent” in terms of this novel.

10. “We were rich in Iran, weren’t we? Weren’t we pooldar? p.143 bottom- 144 top
“Yes and no, son. Yes and no.”
Why does Esmail ask this of his father? What deeper meaning might there be
to Behrani’s response.

House of Sand and Fog pp.94-109

pp.94-109

1. In what way does the description of Esmail by his father show that he has become Americanized? (page 94)
2. What has brought the change in Nadi’s mood? How does the smell of the dinner
she is preparing and her singing work on Behrani’s mood as well?(page 95)

3. The arrival of a courier car drastically changes Behrani’s fortune. Describe how the
letter from Kathy’s attorney affects him. What does he do? What is he thinking?
What is your interpretation of the scene immediately following in the bathroom?
(pages 96-97)

4. Is the description at the top of page 98 included for pure erotic effect or does it
somehow add to our understanding of Kathy and Lester’s character? How?

5. What emotional and physical risks are Kathy and Lester facing by taking their
relationship to this level?

6. “…it was as if I wasn’t anchored to the ground all the way.” What is the author’s
purpose in using this simile repeatedly throughout the novel?(pages 100-101)

7. Why do you think the author describes Colonel Behrani’s outfit in such great detail? What might be symbolic about the color of his tie? (page 102)
8. “My name is Colonel Massoud Amir Behrani. I wish to speak to Mr. Walsh,
please.” What does this say about Behrani’s past relationship with women?
9 Why has Nadi hung the picture of Behrani and the Shah back up in their bungalo?
(page 108) Of what significance is the presence of the Savakis in this photo?

10. Soraya is described by her father as “stepping into a limousine dressed in ivory
satin….with a spray of baby breath flowers which she wore like a crown.” (page 109) Contrast this to what you know of Kathy and how Behrani treats her.
. ,The Shah’s second wife was named Soraya.